When I first found out I was pregnant with Rembot, I made a video full of stick figure cartoons to the song “You’ve Got a Friend in Me” (get it!?) and showed it to Jack when he got home from work. We were due to close on our first house in just a couple of days, so I lied and said the video was about memories of our time at our apartment.
This is from four years ago, so please forgive my poor editing skills. I had made the video private for about a year, but I publicked (<–not a real word) so you can see how incredibly nerdy I am.
I told Jack I would like to be surprised and not find out the gender, but by the time the 20 week ultrasound came around, he had convinced me to find out, and our monotone tech announced that we were having a girl.
When I was pregnant with Baby Shark, I was adamant about not finding out the gender. “Let’s be surprised!” He wasn’t really into it, but I remained strong through my ultrasound. But, it was discovered that Baby Shark had a problem with her kidneys, so we probably had about a dozen ultrasounds during that pregnancy. During one of those ultrasounds, a tech kept using gender-specific terms. “He’s growing well.” “His right kidney…” Etc., etc.
I was so upset. I felt like my surprise was ruined, so we had the tech put the gender on a piece of paper and stick it in an envelope while I sorted out my feelings. Jack went to work and I moped all day. He convinced me to open the envelope, so we decided to at least try to make it fun. Later that night, we uploaded a video to Facebook showing the process. We had gone to a local bakery, gave them the envelope, and had them write the gender on a brownie. We took Rembot out to dinner, and the waitstaff seemed as excited as we were. They all marched out with a brownie and candles and screamed “It’s a girl!” The video was a fantastic way to tell our family and friends.
So this pregnancy, I decided, enough is enough. We are not – under any circumstances – finding out the gender. Jack protested, but I stood firm. Had an ultrasound; didn’t find out the gender. Because kidney issues can be hereditary, they wanted us to do a follow up ultrasound. Another chance to find out the gender. We did not.
And Jack was disturbingly upset. He wanted to know the gender of his baby. And because of HIPAA laws, the ultrasound tech wouldn’t tell him, simply because I’m the patient and I didn’t want us to find out.
“It just makes me feel like I had.. nothing to do with this.”
Bah. On one hand, come on. Be surprised with me. Won’t it be fun? But, on the other hand, I realize that Jack and I are two completely different people. We like different things. We switch radio stations on each other in the car. He likes background noise, and I prefer quiet. He’s better at listening; I’m better at reading. So on, and so forth.
And I want to be surprised. And he does not.
When he was out of the room, I whispered to the tech to please write the gender down. She wrote the gender on a post-it note and I shoved it in my pocket. And then I stuffed it in my wallet.
At home, I transferred the note into an envelope, and then another envelope, and then ANOTHER envelope, and wrote Jack a little note, telling him that while I would much prefer that he find out the gender with me at the hospital when our baby is born, he is welcome to find out on his own, and I will respect whatever decision he makes.
I also wrote NOOOOOOOO DON’T OPEN MEEEEEEEEEE on every single envelope. :)
I gave it to him, and he was thrilled. He waited a solid week and a half to open it, and, as I had requested, videotaped his reaction so I could one day watch it. (Can you tell we’re super into videotaping things?)
So Jack knows the gender. And I do not.
“Can I post the video to NiceGirlNotes so your readers can watch it and then I’ll delete it? Everyone will know but you, won’t that be fun!?”
Ummmm.
:)



















I love that you make things so fun no matter what the circumstance! Personally we never knew with any of our 4 kids, and we both loved it that way. It wasn’t even an option for us to find out since we didn’t get ultrasounds. While I think it would be cool for him to post the video AFTER the baby is born, I don’t know if you can trust the INTERNET to keep a secret from you. I don’t know, maybe I’m cynical but I can’t imagine someone wouldn’t accidentally or on purpose tell you.
[Reply]
Roo Reply:
February 17th, 2012 at 9:42 am
Right, totally. I was thinking about having him tell one of my friends so she can snag some baby clothes and wash them for me, but even that makes me nervous!
[Reply]
I was pregnant with both my boys in Germany. Our first we both found out- but our second I really wanted to wait. My hubs dind’t really want to, but went along with it. I was CONVINCED I was having a girl. When my sweet second little boy came out I was shocked, but my husband, not so much. I came to find out weeks later that apparently HIPPA does NOT exist in Germany because my husband asked the doctor and found out, as did my best girlfriend (and her husband) who was also pregnant and seeing the same doctor! Ca-RAZY. But I’m super glad I didn’t know that they all knew, and I’m cool with it now and will likely give my husband the option to find out again if he wants to, but I think he won’t- He knows he missed out on one hullava surprise! Sorry for the book. I hope you post the Jack video after the baby is born- I’m sure it’s hilarious.
[Reply]
Roo Reply:
February 17th, 2012 at 9:44 am
Whaaaat, that IS crazy!!! I can’t imagine going to my doctor and saying, heyyyy can you tell me if my friend Katherine is having a boy or a girl?
[Reply]
OMG THAT VIDEO IS SOO SO CUTE!!!
[Reply]
Roo Reply:
February 17th, 2012 at 9:43 am
Haha, thanks, Rachel!
[Reply]
Let him! I want to have a secret, too. :)
[Reply]
Roo Reply:
February 17th, 2012 at 11:29 am
Ha! :)
[Reply]
Waiting to find out is so much fun! We didn’t know what we were having either time, first a girl, then a boy. But the second time around I guess the doctor forgot we didn’t know so we had to wait almost 10 minutes after our son was born for someone to tell us it was a boy! (I had c-sections with both due to complications) So we just sat there speculating until someone paid us enough attention to ask. Still funny.
[Reply]
That is the best video. It brought a tear to my eye!
[Reply]
Please post it! I’m dying to see his reaction. I am way to curious of a person to wait. I found out the genders of both kids at week 18. But the thing is, I knew what we were having. My intuition told me on day one!
[Reply]
This would so not work for us. My husband would lord it over me until I went crazy.
[Reply]
I would love to see the video!!! I found out with both my boys and while I always planned to not find out, I also found myself blurting out to the tech, “So what are we having?!” before I could stop myself. I am also a planner and it would drive me crazy to be less then 100% prepared for the tiny human I growing. I always said that if I had another, I would be surprised, but who are we kidding, I would totally find out again.
Also, I am really good at keeping secrets. Especially since you live on the direct opposite side of the country from me. :)
[Reply]
I seriously just teared up at the end of that video. You guys are ridiculously adorable!!
We were the exact opposite in that we scheduled an early u/s to find out the gender. We just couldn’t wait! And it was RIGHT before Xmas so we surprised our families with the news on Christmas morning.
I love what you guys did for finding out about baby shark though.
Um, I really like Jack’s idea. I want to know!!
[Reply]
Please, please, please can Jack post the video????
Also, how did you make that adorable first video? I really would like to give that a try.
I still think it’s another girl. Since I have three boys, I just think it’s the way that it goes.
[Reply]
dumb mom Reply:
February 17th, 2012 at 5:31 pm
As a mom to 3 Dudes I agree with you, Chelle. It’s just the way it goes. Or at least it better be b/c that’s what happened to me and I kinda like the universe to treat everyone equally. I’m bratty like that:)
[Reply]
I really think you should let him do it! I swear I won’t tell!! lol.
[Reply]
[...] Roo at Nice Girl Notes is having a baby soon and guess what? Her husband knows the gender and she does not. [...]
Tell Jack to text me. I’m ready…
[Reply]
Very nice job on the video…what a sweet way to tell Jack. We were surprised the first time, and found out the other two times,but loved every single time…and that’s what counts. Right?
[Reply]
I’m like Jack. No way could I go the whole time and not know if I knew the information was available to me.
[Reply]
Having never been in the “What’s the gender” situation, I don’t honestly know what I’d do. I think I’d be like you tho, and rather be surprised.
Also, you coulda warned us about the giant scary ass Donnie Darko’s cousin of a rabbit in the video!
[Reply]
oh that is so cute that he knows and you don’t!!!! that’s great compromization! if that’s a word. we didn’t find out on any of ours. all three. boy, boy and then boy. oh boy!!!!! so…..if there ever were another one (which by the way my husband adimately refuses to allow) I would TOTALLY find out. Not that I didn’t LOVE LOVE LOVE not knowing. It’s the way we love to do it! It’s such an awesome feeling to be pushing and sooooooo beyond excited to find out what it’s gonna be!!!! But……IF there were a 4th (maybe like in 3-4 years once my husband forgets how hectic it was!!!) I would want to know just to mentally prepare myself. honestly, i would want a girl and i would just want those extra 20 weeks to accept that we are baby boy making phenoms! awesome video!!!!!!!
[Reply]
Chelle Reply:
February 18th, 2012 at 7:47 am
Shannon,
I had to find out what we were having because I always wanted a girl and they were all boys! I would have gone for it again, but my hubby went and had a vasectomy six weeks after the last one was born. He was THROUGH. I understood and said it was his choice. I wasn’t going to get the surgery though because I was willing to have more kids just to get my girl, so if something ever happened to him, I wanted my option left open.
Now I’m 47 and had a hysterectomy a couple years ago. So I have to pray for granddaughters. *Sigh* It’s so hard when these men won’t cooperate. I would still consider adopting a little girl from China though. I think that would be total awesomeness.
On the last sonogram, when we found out it was another boy, I actually smacked my husband. Apparently, he only made boy sperm. His brother has three girls. I picked the wrong brother???? WTF?
[Reply]
I’m kind of new here, so I cried, then went back and read the linked post and cried again. You are an amazing mom and what a nice gift to the world that you can mix humor with emotion and truth so creatively, and share it with so many people. I am also older, so when I see young people (my daughter and her husband also), who are really thoughtful about what they do and how they do them on a day to day basis, it gives me so much hope about the future generations. Because I am older, sometimes I feel like I’m spying on you (ha!)because your readers seem to be all my daughters age (gee I wonder why LOL). But, hey, I have a few things to learn too, and I like your attitude young lady! (that’s my gramma voice).
[Reply]
Cute video! And although I think I could handle my husband knowing and everyone else not, I am pretty sure it would just bug me to no end for everyone else to know and me not to. But alas, we are done so I have to live vicariously though everyone else… Can’t wait to find out what gender baby #3 is!! So exciting!
[Reply]
Awesome video! I might have to borrow (steal) the idea if I ever get pregnant. Can’t wait to find out what you’re having. I say if you wait, we should wait!
[Reply]
So I just found your website via Pintrest via the dollhouse drawer post. LOVE.
Also, I wanted to throw out there that that we have a 3,2, and soon to be 1 year old this month. (sort of like you). Your post about “hiding the pregnancy”, yeah, that was me for the first many weeks of little girl (#3). Funny, my husband would have been ok to “not know”, while I needed to know who I was growing inside of me.
Anyway, congratulations, Mama :) I am terribly excited for your family. And I look forward to reading more of your blog!!!
[Reply]
Roo Reply:
March 6th, 2012 at 9:22 am
Thank you so much, Nicole! :) I may be coming to you for advice very soon. :)
[Reply]
I don’t know how I missed this one, but it warmed my heart more than anything else I’ve read this year. Ugh, I’m getting sentimental. Time to go buy a beer and tear open a beef jerky.
[Reply]